The second week of April began quietly, with a few snow flurries and early-morning new ice on my home pond. The ice was gone by midmorning and on the ninth, the first mallards arrived. Males and females, they swam in the narrow open channel between the ice and the bank or loafed on the ice platform in the center of the pond. And they came every day thereafter.
Seeds on the deck railing attracted the usual juncos, chickadees, and nuthatches. But one day a raven came. It marched the full length of the railing, snapping up seeds of all sizes, one at a time. Reaching the end of the line of seeds, it turned around and did the same in the other direction, until its crop began to bulge. Raven visitations have been extremely rare this winter, and I wonder what prompted this one to come.
One evening, I glanced out my front window and saw a hawk sitting on a dark lump on the pond ice. A juvenile northern goshawk had killed a male mallard, and a few fluffy feathers were strewn about. The hawk had one foot clamped on the duck’s bill, with the other one on the body. As the hawk pecked at the duck’s head, getting small tidbits (the mallard was past caring), it frequently looked all around, as if to check for possible thieves. Then the hawk tore off some body feathers and took a couple of bites, grabbed the duck’s head with one foot and flapped laboriously over to a nearby snowy bank, the prey dangling limply and precariously just above the water surface.The duck probably weighed about as much as the predator, so this was quite a load (although goshawks are known to take prey more than twice their own body mass).

Once on the bank, the hawk changed its foothold from head to wing, but the prey slid down the steep little bank into the pond and floated immediately under a ledge of snow that stuck out from the bank. Now the hawk had a problem: from the bank above the duck, all it could grab was a wing, while the body was lodged under the ledge. The hawk tried several times to haul the body up over the ledge and onto the bank, taking intermittent rests in nearby trees. By now, it was starting to get dark, and the frustrated, slightly bedraggled hawk took off for a nighttime perch somewhere else. Apparently, the hawk never figured out that if it pulled the wing toward the ice, the body would come out from under the snow ledge and be available. Alas, no photo of all this action was possible without disturbing the process.
Meanwhile, although a squirrel scolded continuously, avian activity on the deck railing continued as usual, with the addition of a face-off between a nuthatch and a junco, which was won by the nuthatch. Ten minutes after the hawk left, other mallards came back to the pond where they’d spent most of the day.
By six-thirty the next morning, there was no sign of the dead mallard in the pond and no new scuffle marks in the snow on the bank. There were muddy footprints, probably of a dog, crossing the ice platform, but at some distance from the place where the duck was last seen. Hmmm, did the hawk come back and figure out what to do or did somebody else appropriate the prey? That all left a frustrated observer too!
Ah, but late that afternoon, I looked out my window again. And there was a river otter, munching away at the carcass on the ice platform, not far from where the hawk had struggled with it. The otter tore big gouts of muscle from the keeled sternum and stripped the long bones bare, mauling the carcass in all directions to expose more edible tissues. By the time the otter went for a cleansing swim, there was just a messy pile of feathers, guts, and bloody bones. None of that disturbed the mallards loafing at the other end of the ice platform!
After the otter swam around the pond (which did scare the loafing ducks) and departed, an eagle arrived. It found a few bitsleft by the otter, gobbled up the intestine, tore the tough gizzard into chunks, and flew off with the bones of the pectoral girdle and parts of two wings in its talons. A raven arrived in the evening, but too late! Only loose feathers and bloody ice were left. And so the duck’s death profited three other critters. A fitting end to the story!

Note: The bird I watched was probably a year old (possibly two): its plumage was very dark brown with no sign of transition to adult plumage. Goshawks sometimes start breeding when they are only a year old and still in juvenile plumage, perhaps chiefly in low-density populations where competition for territories is not intense, but tend to have low reproductive success. Some reports indicate that individuals that don’t initiate breeding until age three or four tend to have better nesting success. Foraging experience probably contributes to success at nesting (and having an experienced mate to share chick-feeding duties might help compensate for inexperience in one member of a pair), but many factors, including prey density, prey species, and habitat quality, influence nesting success. Detailed studies are few.